Office workers enjoy a lively team-building exercise with sticky notes on foreheads, fostering collaboration.

Why Labels Other People Give You Take Longer to Change

Labels other people give you change on two schedules. You can drop your own version today. The other person’s version changes only when they see new events and connect them to you.

Labels from other people work differently from the ones you invent. A label you made up exists in your own thinking. You can question it in private, look at the events under it, and stop using it.

A label someone else gave you exists in at least two places. You hold one version. The other person holds another. Sometimes a third version shows up in a record, like a school file or a performance review. You can change your version. You can’t change theirs.

The other person also keeps acting on their version. A teacher who expects less from a student might call on that student less often. A family that calls one child “the strong one” might keep handing that child the hard jobs. Those actions produce new events, and the new events seem to confirm the label.

So these labels take two kinds of work. The first kind happens in your head. You look at the word, ask what actually happened, and stop using it. The second kind happens out in the world, over months or years, in front of the people who gave you the label.

Where Outside Labels Come From

Quick Summary: Parents assign the first roles a child hears. Teachers write single phrases onto report cards. Managers repeat a rating year after year until the employee starts using it. Each source hands over a word, and the person who hears that word often enough eventually says it about themselves.

Many labels people use on themselves started with someone else. A parent called you the responsible one. A teacher wrote “talks too much” on a report card. A manager rated you “meets expectations” three years in a row.

You heard the word often enough. Then you started saying it too.

Labeling Theory and the Self-Fulfilling Prophecy

Quick Summary: Howard Becker traced deviance to how other people react to an act (Source: Howard S. Becker, Outsiders, 1963). Robert K. Merton coined “self-fulfilling prophecy” in a 1948 essay (Source: The Antioch Review, Vol. 8, No. 2). A false belief prompts new behavior, and that behavior makes the belief come true.

Sociologists have studied outside labels for decades. In 1963, Howard Becker argued in Outsiders that a deviance label comes from other people applying rules and penalties. The act alone doesn’t decide it. Who notices the act, and how they respond, decides it.

Fifteen years earlier, Robert K. Merton gave the process its best-known name. His essay “The Self-Fulfilling Prophecy” ran in The Antioch Review in the summer of 1948. He defined it as “a false definition of the situation evoking a new behavior which makes the originally false conception come true.”
pbworks
ebsco

His example reads like a short story. He invented the Last National Bank, presided over by Cartwright Millingville, who ran it honestly and properly. A rumor spreads that the bank has money trouble. Depositors pull their money anyway. The withdrawals drain the bank, and it fails. The rumor started out false and ended up true.
blogspot

Banks only opened the essay. The bank run gets remembered most, but most of the essay explains the dynamics of ethnic and racial conflict in the US at the time. A group gets labeled. People act on the label. Then the events their actions produce seem to prove the label right.
unibo

Outside labels follow the same path. A teacher who expects less from you calls on you less. You get less practice, and your answers get shakier. Soon the teacher’s label looks accurate.

Cooley’s Looking-Glass Self

Quick Summary: Cooley split self-image into three imagined steps (Source: Charles Horton Cooley, Human Nature and the Social Order). People react to a judgment they guessed, not one anyone spoke. That guess can keep running for decades, long after the person who made the original judgment has forgotten it.

People work out who they are partly by guessing how other people see them. In 1902, University of Michigan sociologist Charles Horton Cooley described this process in Human Nature and the Social Order. He called it the “looking-glass self,” using an old word for a mirror.

Cooley broke the process into three steps. First, you imagine how you appear to another person. Then you imagine how that person judges what they see. After that, you feel something about the judgment, such as pride or shame.

Cooley called the second step essential, even though the mirror comparison leaves it out. A mirror shows you your face. It shows you nobody’s opinion. You supply the opinion yourself, as a guess. Sometimes the guess matches what the other person thinks. Sometimes it doesn’t.

Picture a meeting. You walk in, and a coworker frowns. Before anyone speaks, you’ve already guessed what the frown means about you, and you feel something about that guess. Maybe the coworker just opened a bad email.

The same guess can keep running for decades. Years after a teacher wrote “talks too much,” you might still picture that teacher’s judgment every time you speak up at work. The teacher probably forgot you long ago. Your guess about the teacher kept going.

The Pygmalion Effect and Teacher Expectations

Quick Summary: Robert Rosenthal and Lenore Jacobson tested teacher expectations at an elementary school they called Oak School (Source: Rosenthal & Jacobson, Pygmalion in the Classroom, 1968). Teachers received the names of randomly chosen “bloomers.” Those children’s reported IQ gains showed up mostly in first and second grade.

Cooley described the guess you make about someone else’s judgment. Two researchers later tested what happens when that judgment comes from a fake source.

Robert Rosenthal, a Harvard social psychologist, worked with Lenore Jacobson, a former principal of the South San Francisco school where they ran the research. All students in grades one through six took a nonverbal IQ test near the start of the school year. Teachers heard that the students had taken the Harvard Test of Inflected Acquisition. No such test existed.

Then came the label. Teachers heard that 20 percent of the children showed unusual potential for intellectual growth. The researchers drew those names with a table of random numbers. Eight months later, the singled-out children showed significantly greater IQ gains than the rest.

The result has limits, and they matter. The reported gains came mostly from first and second graders, six- and seven-year-olds tested with an IQ instrument that critics called inappropriate for their age. The IQ effects set off a long, bitter controversy, partly because later experiments produced conflicting results.

One follow-up connects directly to outside labels. In a 1984 synthesis of 18 experiments, Stephen Raudenbush tested the idea that the better teachers already knew their students when they got the new label, the smaller the effect would turn out. If that idea holds, it fits the rest of this post. A teacher who already holds a version of you might not swap it for a new one.

Stereotype Threat and Group Labels

Quick Summary: Stereotype threat attaches pressure to group membership, not to the individual (Source: Steele & Aronson, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 69, 797–811). One sentence describes the test as changing SAT-adjusted performance. Sackett and colleagues later showed that the raw gap between groups remained (Source: Sackett, Hardison & Cullen, American Psychologist, 2004).

Some outside labels don’t name you. They name a group you belong to. You might not believe the label at all. You can still feel pressure from knowing other people believe it, especially when your performance could look like proof.

Psychologists call this stereotype threat. In 1995, Claude Steele of Stanford and Joshua Aronson defined it as the risk of confirming a negative stereotype about your group as true of yourself.

That year, they tested it with Black and White Stanford undergraduates. Each student worked through hard verbal questions taken from the Graduate Record Examination. One group heard that the test measured intellectual ability. The other group heard that the exercise studied problem solving and measured nothing about ability.

Steele and Aronson compared scores after adjusting for each student’s earlier SAT results. In the group told the test measured ability, Black students scored lower than White students. In the other group, that difference largely went away.

The study often gets described as finding more than it did. The result depended on that SAT adjustment, and the raw gap between groups never disappeared. Paul Sackett and colleagues made this point in American Psychologist in 2004. Researchers still argue about how large the effect runs in everyday testing.

The core finding still holds. The students stayed the same. So did the questions and the time limit. Only one sentence of description changed. A label held by other people moved the scores through the situation, and nobody said the label out loud.

Forced Ranking and Labels a Company Writes Down

Quick Summary: Performance reviews put verbal judgments into permanent files. Stack ranking required a bottom tier no matter how well the team performed (Source: SHRM). Microsoft dropped its five-point curve in November 2013 (Source: The Register). Jack Welch defended the practice in the Wall Street Journal.

Workplaces turn outside labels into records. A rating like “exceeds expectations” or “needs improvement” goes into a file. It affects pay, promotions, and sometimes whether you keep the job. A manager who never worked with you can read that phrase later and form a view of you from it.

Forced ranking, also called stack ranking, took this further. Under forced ranking, a manager has to sort a team into fixed percentages. A set share of people must get the top rating, and a set share must get the bottom one, no matter how well the team did overall.

General Electric made the approach famous under CEO Jack Welch in the 1980s. His version sorted employees into the top 20 percent, the middle 70 percent, and the bottom 10 percent. People in the bottom group could lose their jobs. Motorola, IBM, Ford, and other companies built similar systems.

Microsoft rated employees against each other on a scale of one to five. In 2012, a Vanity Fair article blamed the system for much of what it called Microsoft’s lost decade. On November 12, 2013, Microsoft’s head of human resources, Lisa Brummel, emailed employees to end it. “No more curve,” she wrote.

Forced ranking still has defenders. After Microsoft’s announcement, Welch wrote a Wall Street Journal op-ed arguing that the approach works when a company does it right.

The math still tells you something about outside labels. Under a forced curve, somebody had to get the bottom label every year. That label came partly from what people did and partly from a percentage the company required. A strong team still needed a bottom 10 percent. So an employee could do good work and still end up there.

Family Roles in Encanto

Quick Summary: Encanto turns each Madrigal grandchild’s magical gift into a household job. Luisa’s strength starts to fail under the town’s constant demands. Isabela agreed to marry Mariano only to please the family. Bruno’s visions got him blamed for the trouble he foresaw, and the family stopped saying his name.

Families give children the first labels they hear. One child becomes the responsible one, another the funny one, another the one who causes problems. These roles help a family run, because they tell everyone who handles what. They also leave out every part of a child that doesn’t fit the role.

Disney’s 2021 animated film Encanto builds its story around this. The Madrigal family lives in a magical house in the mountains of Colombia. Each child receives a special gift, and the gift turns into the child’s role.

Luisa, 19, has superhuman strength. The town relies on her to move buildings and bridges. Midway through the film, she admits to her younger sister Mirabel that the constant demands overwhelm her. Soon after, her strength starts to fail.

Isabela can make flowers bloom anywhere, and the family treats her as the perfect one. She has agreed to marry a local man named Mariano. Later, she admits she never wanted to marry him and only said yes for the family’s sake. When she accidentally grows a lopsided cactus, she finds it beautiful.

Bruno, their uncle, can see the future. When his visions showed trouble coming, the family blamed him for causing it. He disappeared, and the family stopped saying his name. Mirabel later learns he never left. He had stayed hidden inside the house the whole time.

Mirabel, 15, received no gift. When things start going wrong, her grandmother blames her for the family’s troubles.

Each role started from something real. Luisa has real strength. Isabela can grow flowers. But the family kept using each role long after it stopped describing the whole person, and that caused problems for everyone.

How Cognitive Defusion Works on Your Own Version

Quick Summary: Acceptance and commitment therapy calls the private work cognitive defusion. Rapidly repeating a negative self-label cut both its believability and its sting (Source: Masuda, Hayes, Sackett & Twohig, Behaviour Research and Therapy, 2004). Discomfort dropped within seconds, while believability took longer to fall (Source: Masuda et al., Behavior Modification, 2009).

Your own version of an outside label changes through private work. Psychologists have studied one method for it closely.

Acceptance and commitment therapy, or ACT, calls the method cognitive defusion. Defusion techniques try to change the context a thought shows up in, rather than its content or how often it comes. The best-known exercise uses a single word. A therapist picks a word with a strong negative self-referential charge for the client, such as “fraud” or “stupid,” and the client repeats it for about 45 seconds.

In 2004, Akihiko Masuda, Steven Hayes, and colleagues tested this. Their paper showed that the “milk, milk, milk” defusion technique reduced the distress and believability of negative self-referential thoughts. It also beat a distraction task and a thought-control task on both measures. The paper’s own title calls it a ninety-year-old technique.

A 2009 follow-up timed the effect. Discomfort leveled off after 3 to 10 seconds of rapid repetition, while believability took 20 to 30 seconds.

So the private half can move fast. Half a minute of repetition changed how much people believed their own word. It changed nothing about the version other people hold, and the next section picks up there.

Your Version Changes First, Theirs Changes Later

Quick Summary: Private questioning removes your own copy of a label. The other person’s memory keeps its copy. That copy updates only when the holder sees new events and links them to you, and some holders never update while you still know them.

Private questioning works on your own version of an outside label. You can look at “the difficult one” or “the responsible one” and ask what actually happened. You can set the word aside in your own thinking.

The other person’s version needs something else. It changes only when that person sees new events and connects them to you. That takes time, and it depends on them. Some people update their view quickly. Others take years. Some may never update, even when you know them.

You can’t control which kind of person you’re dealing with. A parent might still introduce you as “the shy one” at 45. A former manager might still describe you to a recruiter the way you worked eight years ago.

So two things stay true at once. You can stop believing a label, and other people can keep using it. If you wait for them to change before you change, you might wait for years. If you pretend their version doesn’t exist, it will surprise you each time it comes up.

Here comes the uncomfortable part. You hold versions of other people too. Maybe you still think of a sibling by a role they had at 12. Maybe you still describe a former coworker by how they acted in their first month. They can’t edit your version either.

How Outside Labels Shape Hope

Quick Summary: Other people’s expectations decide which tasks reach you. Those expectations also narrow what you let yourself want. A child repeatedly called “not a math person” may quietly give up on engineering. Holding hope against such a label means keeping two outcomes open at once.

Outside labels shape what people let you try. In Encanto, the town sent Luisa every heavy job because of her gift. Under forced ranking, the curve decided who got raises and who got warnings.

Over time, those labels can also shape what you let yourself hope for. If enough adults call a child “not a math person,” the child might stop hoping to study engineering.

Hoping for something an outside label rules out means holding two possibilities. Other people might keep seeing you the old way. You might do the thing anyway, and some of them might eventually notice.

Hester Prynne’s Scarlet Letter

Quick Summary: Hawthorne’s 1850 novel puts a scarlet A on Hester’s dress. Seven years of sewing, nursing, and charity changed how neighbors read that A (Source: Nathaniel Hawthorne, The Scarlet Letter, ch. 13). Hester controlled her own actions, and the town controlled its interpretation.

Nathaniel Hawthorne wrote a novel about this in 1850. The Scarlet Letter takes place in Puritan Boston. Hester Prynne has a child outside her marriage, and the town sentences her to wear a scarlet A on her dress. The A stands for adultery.

Hester keeps wearing the letter. She embroiders it with elaborate needlework, which makes it stand out even more. She supports herself and her daughter by sewing. She nurses sick neighbors and brings food to poor families.

By the novel’s thirteenth chapter, seven years have passed. Hawthorne writes that many people in town no longer read the A the way the judges meant it. “They said that it meant Able,” he writes.

The letter itself never changed. Hester kept wearing it. The change came from two places. Hester did specific things for years in front of the people who had labeled her. Over those same years, some of those people became willing to read the letter another way.

She couldn’t make the second part happen. She could only keep doing the first.

Questions and Responses

What does looking-glass self mean?

Charles Horton Cooley coined the term in 1902. It describes how people imagine how they appear to others, imagine how others judge them, and then feel something about that imagined judgment.

What did Steele and Aronson’s 1995 study find?

Black students scored lower than White students on a verbal test when told it measured ability. When told it measured nothing about ability, the SAT-adjusted difference largely went away. The raw gap remained.

Why did Microsoft drop stack ranking?

On November 12, 2013, HR head Lisa Brummel emailed employees ending the forced curve, writing, ‘No more curve.’ A 2012 Vanity Fair article had blamed the system for much of Microsoft’s lost decade.

Why do other people’s labels take longer to change than your own?

You can drop your own version privately. The other person’s version changes only when they see new events and connect them to you, and that timing depends on them.

How can you change the way other people see you?

Do things the old label wouldn’t predict, in front of the people who use it, without explaining them. Their view changes only after they see new events themselves.

Comments

Leave a Reply